I STILL KNOW WHAT YOU DID LAST SUMMER (1998)
Julie's back in college with her new friend, and they win a weekend trip to an island. On the way there, someone dies, and then the girls are tormented on the island.
From Geoff on IMDb
I have very fond memories of I STILL KNOW. I remember my mom taking me and my older sister to see it when it came out. I couldn't have been no more than 12 years old, but I loved it. Obviously, now as an adult looking back, I can see the film for what it is. But it will always hold that childhood charm, I guess.